Raad: Alien smuggling mandatory minimum not cruel & unusual

In U.S. v. Raad, No. 03-15300 (April 21, 2005), the Court rejected a challenge to the imposition of a five-year mandatory minimum sentence for smuggling three or more aliens in violation of 8 U.S.C. § 1324(B)(2)(B)(iii). The Court rejected the argument that this punishmnent was "cruel and unusual" punishment under the Eighth Amendment. The Court noted that it had previously upheld mandatory minimums, and found that the five-year punishment was not "cruel and unusual" simply because it fell at the high end of the Guideline range.